.png){kind=small}
As a not-for-profit (NFP) Board member, your oversight responsibilities extend beyond the Board's legal responsibilities . The effectiveness of your CEO is one of the most significant factors influencing your organisation’s success. Yet, many Boards struggle with structured CEO performance evaluation, capability development, and succession planning.
A strong CEO ensures operational effectiveness, strategic execution, and organisational resilience. But how can your Board actively contribute to building leadership capability at the top?
In this article, we explore how NFP Boards can strengthen CEO effectiveness without overstepping governance boundaries. We will also address vicarious liability, compliance responsibilities, and best practices in overseeing CEO performance.
The Board’s Role in CEO Capability Development
NFP Boards have a unique governance responsibility when it comes to CEO performance. The CEO is the bridge between governance and operations, responsible for executing the Board’s strategic direction while managing organisational resources. Effective oversight involves ensuring the CEO has the necessary skills, support, and accountability mechanisms to succeed.
Why CEO Development Is a Governance Priority
Boards often focus on financial risk, compliance, and operational oversight, but neglecting CEO capability can be equally detrimental. A CEO who lacks the right skills or support can expose the organisation to significant risks, including:
Failure to execute strategy: Without strong leadership, even the best Board-approved strategy will falter.
Increased legal and compliance risks: A CEO who is unaware of governance obligations can expose the Board to vicarious liability.
Cultural and reputational damage: A leader who fails to foster a compliant, ethical, or engaged workplace can threaten an organisation’s stability.
High turnover and succession challenges: Lack of leadership development means no pipeline of future leaders, leaving the organisation vulnerable.
As custodians of the organisation, Boards have a responsibility to proactively support and evaluate CEO performance, ensuring both capability and accountability.
How Boards Can Build CEO Capability Without Overstepping
One of the most challenging aspects of Board governance is understanding where oversight ends and operational control begins. Boards are not responsible for managing the CEO day-to-day, but they do have a duty to ensure the CEO is competent and well-supported.
Clarity of purpose with clear goals – Ensuring that your CEO is clear on their purpose and their contribution is a critical factor in driving performance and achievement of strategy. Clear links between the organisational strategy and the goals and remit of a CEO is a foundation of success.
Implement a Structured CEO Performance Review Process - A formal, transparent, and regular CEO evaluation is critical to maintaining effectiveness in leadership. Boards that fail to conduct formal CEO evaluations risk subjective decision-making and leadership stagnation.
Invest in Leadership Development and Executive Coaching - A Board that prioritises CEO capability fosters long-term organisational success. A well-supported CEO is more likely to lead effectively, adapt to changing demands, and uphold best practices in governance.
Address CEO Underperformance within Governance Bounds - Even the best leaders will face challenges, and as Board members, it is your duty to address CEO underperformance in a way that is both ethical and governance-compliant.
Key strategies include:
Issue escalation frameworks: Ensure there is a clear process for raising and addressing concerns about CEO performance; ensuring the incumbent CEO is aware of the consequences of sustained under performance
Remediation before termination: If performance concerns arise, Boards should investigate whether appropriate support, training, or mentorship could resolve the issue before considering dismissal.
Alignment with legal and compliance obligations: CEO evaluations and potential terminations must align with employment law and governance standards to avoid legal complications.
Governance failures often occur when Boards either ignore warning signs or react too slowly to correct leadership issues. Foresight and structured engagement are crucial.
Final Thoughts: CEO Oversight as a Core Governance Responsibility
Boards cannot afford to be passive when it comes to CEO performance and capability. Strong governance requires proactive engagement, to include clarity of role purpose, clear expectations and goal setting, structured performance reviews and leadership development.
By embedding these best practices into your governance approach, your Board can ensure not only the CEO’s success but also the long-term resilience of your organisation.
Is your Board actively investing in CEO capability? If not, now is the time to start.
Comments